Continue to Reach Out
or Time to Leave Out?
There are some within the georgist movement who are opposed to
offering HGI courses to prisoners. They suppose that prisoners
lack either the intellect or the credibility to help the georgist
movement grow; they believe that their limited resources are
wasted on them. Some say that associating with prisoners taints
our other activities in people's minds. When I come right out and
state this position, it sounds absurd -- but there it is.
First, and most important, the term "prisoner" should not be
thought of as a class of people, but rather as someone confined
in a place where numerous classes of people can be found. For
example: to someone who knows the difference between an ocelot, a
lion, a jaguar, a bobcat and a lynx -- not to mention a persian,
siamese or an abyssinian -- people who glibly claim to "know all
about cats" are probably not worth talking to.
People in prison are as diverse as the whole society -- and
this is clearly seen today, with our exploding prison population.
The major difference between prisoners and non-prisoners is that
the overwhelming majority of prisoners come from broken or
dysfunctional family backgrounds, have suffered many forms of
abuse, and enter prison with little formal education. Their self-
esteem is -- for obvious reasons -- extremely low. They find in
HGI courses a way to improve their self-esteem and their basic
But some critics begrudge them this, declaring that once they
get out of prison, the georgists won't hear from them again.
Would the Nike shoe company refuse to sell shoes to Indians
living on reservations, because they probably won't wear the logo
outside the reservation?
Let's remember that inmates are not receiving free courses.
They pay the same fee that others do. The HGI's extremely low
prices make its courses attractive to prisoners -- even so,
though, they have to save for two months to enroll in one. The
average pay for an inmate is $23. Out of this, they must supply
their own necessities such as soap, toothpaste, stationery, etc.
A doctor visit is $4. The average inmate, buying nothing but the
barest necessities, can save about $16 per month. (The HGI's
basic course is $27.)
Actually, as I see it, we need to enroll more prisoners in HGI
courses. If we could enroll 20% of the inmates in the
Pennsylvania state system alone, we would have 7,000 more
Yes, but perhaps they are not the "right" sort of students;
perhaps such a strong association with the "dregs of society" in
prison would harm our reputation. What would Henry George himself
say about that? In Social Problems he says this:
Many there are, too depressed, too embruted with hard toil
and the struggle for animal existence, to think for
themselves. Therefore the obligation devolves with all the
more force on those who can. If thinking men are few, then
they are for that reason all the more powerful. Let no man
imagine that he has no influence. Whoever he may be, and
wherever he may be placed, the man who thinks becomes a
light and a power.
Or are prisoners not smart enough? If not, then why do
prisoners, who lack so much, have an easier time grasping
George's thesis than middle-class college graduates?
One real problem I find today is the saturation of fictional
prison dramas, moves, and exaggerated prison documents that too
many people accept as factual. In the real world, everything in
prison life is micro-managed. Movement is limited. Rules are
numerous to the point of accidental contradiction. Education
consists of a GED program. There are no student loans or college
scholarship programs in prisons. The only avenue available is
self-study, and low-cost correspondence programs -- which helps
to explain the popularity of the HGI's program.
Maybe it would be fair to point out that I am biased on this
issue: I have been teaching georgist political economy from
prison since 1990 and the experience has meant a great deal to
-- Thomas M. Lyons -- March, 2001
Progress & Poverty - Definitions - Capital - Law of Rent - Booms & Busts - The Remedy - Links